Before the money moves

The most expensive decisions an owner makes get the least outside input. That’s backwards, and it’s fixable.

Research didn’t say no. It said where the yes was going to be hard.

Erik Wolf6 min read

Picture the meeting where a company decides to open a second location.

There’s a spreadsheet. There’s a lease option with a deadline on it. There’s an operations lead who has already sketched the floor plan, a sales lead who’s sure the territory is underserved, and an owner who has been thinking about this for two years and has, if they’re honest, already decided. The conversation is about how and when. Nobody in the room is asking whether.

Look around that table and notice who’s sitting at it. Every person there either works for the owner or is about to be paid by them. The accountant, the broker, the contractor, the team. Good people, all of them, and every one of them has a reason to want the yes.

The customers who would have to show up at the new location aren’t in the room. Neither are the people who would have to staff it, refer to it, or partner with it. The decision depends on them more than on anyone at the table, and they’re the only ones nobody asked.

The bigger the decision, the fewer outsiders get a say

This is the pattern I’d most like owners to notice in themselves. Small decisions get plenty of outside input. A new logo goes in front of a dozen people. A pricing page gets tested. A trade-show booth gets debated for weeks.

The big ones don’t. A new service line, a new market, a new building: these are the calls that can make or break a year, and they’re usually made by the smallest group of people with the most in common. The owner, a few trusted lieutenants, and whatever advisors the owner already talks to. And as I’ve written before, everyone advising the owner knows the customers only through the owner.

It isn’t arrogance. It’s momentum. By the time an idea is big enough to need a room, the owner has lived with it long enough to love it. The room is there to execute, not to question.

This is where the fear of No lives

In the first piece in this series I wrote about the fear of No: the quiet reason owners avoid research, which is that nobody commissions a study hoping to hear their idea is unwanted.

That fear is mild when the stakes are small. Nobody loses sleep over whether customers like the new brochure. It’s at its strongest right before the biggest decisions, because that’s when the owner has the most invested in the answer. Asking the people the idea depends on feels like inviting someone to talk you out of the thing you’ve already fallen for.

So the asking gets skipped at exactly the moment it’s worth the most.

What a viability study actually asks

The useful version of this research isn’t a survey asking whether people like the idea. Almost everyone likes an idea when it’s described to them and costs them nothing.

It asks the people the decision depends on two harder questions. What would make you commit? And what would stop you?

It also asks more than one group. The buyers, yes. But also the people who would have to deliver the thing, refer to it, run it, or join it. An idea can be wanted by the people it serves and still fail because the people it needs won’t sign up.

Viable, but

Here’s one study that showed me why the second group matters. I’ve changed the details.

A founder wanted to bring several independent specialist practices under one roof, with a shared back office and referrals between them. The people those practices serve would have one place to go instead of several. It was a good idea, and the founder came to us wanting confirmation of that.

We talked to both sides: the clients, and the practitioners who would have to join.

The clients were close to unanimous. It would make an exhausting part of their lives easier. If the founder had stopped there, they’d have had their yes.

The practitioners were a different conversation. They were lukewarm. They worried about giving up their independence, about whether the other practices shared their values, and about what it would cost them to move in.

So the answer was viable, but. The concept was sound and the demand was real. The hard sell wasn’t going to be the customers at all. It was the people the founder needed to sign up first, and that was where the founder’s effort needed to go.

Research didn’t say no. It said where the yes was going to be hard. That’s a much more useful thing to know before any money moves than after.

It’s one study, and I wouldn’t turn it into a rule. But I think about it every time an owner tells me their customers are going to love something. They might. That may not be the question that matters.

The answer is usually a map, not a verdict

Owners tend to imagine research coming back with a grade: go or no-go. Sometimes it does. Sometimes the most valuable thing a study can tell you is “don’t,” and that answer, heard early, is worth more than any yes.

More often, in my experience, what comes back is “yes, but not the way you think.” The idea holds up, and the plan around it needs to change. A different first customer. A different order of operations. A different person to win over before anyone else.

That’s not a reason to avoid asking. It’s the reason to ask. The cost of hearing it is a small fraction of the decision it informs. The cost of not hearing it shows up later, and it shows up all at once.

Before the next big one

If there’s a big decision in front of you this year, here’s the exercise I’d do before the next meeting about it.

Write down every group of people the decision depends on. Not the people in the room. The people outside it whose yes you’re assuming: the customers, the staff, the partners, the referrers.

Then ask yourself honestly which of those groups anyone has actually talked to about this, and who did the talking. If the answer is “nobody,” or “me,” you’re about to make your most expensive decision of the year on secondhand information.

Research won’t make the decision for you. It just makes sure someone outside the room got a say before you made it.


This is adapted from a book I’m working on. Earlier pieces: why owners hate market research, the room you’re never in, and what they say and what they mean. If you have a big decision coming and want to hear from the people it depends on first, that’s what we do at Ophea.