Erik Wolf5 min read
Most research starts with a question the owner already has.
Why are we losing deals? What should the new package include? Would customers pay for this? Someone writes questions designed to answer it, the answers come back, and the study is done. If it was run well, the owner now knows something they didn’t before.
That’s research as a confirmation tool. It’s useful, and it’s how most people think about it. You ask a question, you get an answer, and the answer is about the thing you asked.
The trouble is that the person writing the question is the owner, and the owner is working from inside the room. The questions they think to ask are the ones their own view of the business suggests. The things they’re missing are, almost by definition, the things they wouldn’t think to ask about.
Research as a discovery instrument
The best research works differently. It still answers the question it was given. But it’s built so that it can also answer a bigger one, if the people you’re talking to have something bigger to say.
I’d call that research as a discovery instrument. The difference isn’t the topic or the budget. It’s whether the method leaves room for people to tell you something you didn’t ask for.
A multiple-choice survey can’t do it. It can only record the options you thought to offer. A short call from the account manager can’t do it either, because the customer is managing a relationship while they answer. Neither one leaves room for the answer you weren’t expecting.
What leaves room
In practice, a study can find the unasked question when four things are true.
-
The questions are open. People answer in their own words instead of choosing from yours. The words they reach for, and the things they bring up on their own, are where the surprises show up.
-
Someone neutral is asking. A customer talking to someone who isn’t from the company stops performing for the relationship. They’ll mention the thing they’d never say to the person who handles their account.
-
The conversation is long enough. In a single conversation, the first answers are the polished ones. Somewhere past the opening, once the person realizes nobody is going to argue with them, they start thinking out loud. That’s usually where the thing you didn’t ask about comes up, often sitting right next to the question you did ask.
-
Someone reads for surprise. When the conversations are done, it’s tempting to go straight to the answers to the questions you wrote. The discipline is to also ask: what came up that we didn’t expect? What did people keep mentioning that wasn’t on our list?
None of that is exotic. It’s mostly a matter of not shutting the door.
The ones who rely on you most
Here’s an example of what it looks like when the door stays open. I’ve changed the client and the details to protect their confidentiality, but the shape of what happened is real.
An IT services company supports businesses on three levels of service: basic, managed, and fully outsourced. They were designing their next service package and asked us to find out what clients would value in it. A sensible question, and a common one.
We talked to clients at every level, and to the company’s own team. The package questions got answered. Clients told us what they’d want, what they’d pay for, and what they could live without.
But running through the client conversations was a pattern nobody had asked about. The more a client relied on the company, the less happy that client was. The basic clients were the most satisfied. The managed clients were less so. The fully outsourced clients, the biggest and most valuable accounts, were the least satisfied of all.
That wasn’t in the research plan. Nobody had asked about it. And it’s very likely the finding that matters most to the business, more than anything about the new package. A company planning what to add had just learned something important about what was already there.
It’s one study, and I wouldn’t turn it into a rule about IT services or anything else. The point isn’t that heavy users are always unhappy. The point is that the most consequential finding in the study was one the study wasn’t designed to find, and it only surfaced because the method let people talk.
Why owners don’t plan for this
If the most valuable findings often come from the unasked question, why is so much research built to shut it out?
Partly it’s cost. Open conversations take longer to run and longer to read than a survey with five options per question. Partly it’s comfort. A study that answers exactly what you asked is easy to act on. A study that tells you something you weren’t looking for is harder to hear, especially if it touches something you thought was fine.
And partly it’s the fear of No, which I’ve written about before. Owners don’t only dread being told their new idea is unwanted. They also dread being told that something they’re proud of isn’t working. A tightly scoped study feels safer, because it can only tell you about the thing you pointed it at.
How to leave room in your next study
If you’re commissioning research, or running it yourself, a few habits make the unasked question more likely to show up.
Write your questions, then add one more at the end: is there anything we haven’t asked about that we should have?
Don’t let the person who owns the relationship do the asking.
Give each conversation enough time that people get past the polished answers.
And when you read the results, start with what surprised you before you go to the answers you were looking for. If nothing surprised you, read again.
You can’t plan for the answer to the question you didn’t ask. You can only make sure your method doesn’t shut it out.
This is adapted from a book I’m working on. The client example above has been changed to protect the client’s confidentiality. Earlier pieces: why owners hate market research, what they say and what they mean, and before the money moves. If you want to hear what your customers would tell you if someone left room for it, that’s what we do at Ophea.

